Queen City took it off the car, but neglected to tell GEICO that it was broken. The plan, I guess, was to put it back on the car? 

I can see how they could have forgotten, though. The mirror doesn't look damaged, and you don't realize it is until you touch it. Whereas the driver's-side mirror feels solid, the passenger mirror wiggles and shakes, not where it meets the body, but at the pivot point where you can fold it back. Which is, I'm assuming, what the deer's body did.

Queen City said they'd call GEICO again in the morning to get it resolved. I can't imagine this will hold things up much at all, but I'm sure I just jinxed it by writing that.

I've been heads-down the past three days working on financial stuff for my business, but I should be done by the morning. If so, I'm going to reward myself with a trip down to Queen City to see how things are going. I'm sure they will love the interruption.